Hallmark's "Finding Mr. Christmas" - My New Holiday Obsession

Help! I've fallen down another rabbit hole of holiday cheer and can't get out! My December evenings were already booked solid with cheesy Christmas movies—you know, the kind where a big-city workaholic rediscovers the true meaning of Christmas in a small town with the help of a handsome lumberjack and a quirky cast of characters. But then the holiday season threw a curveball with Hallmark's 'Finding Mr. Christmas,' a reality show that has me completely hooked! Ten ruggedly handsome men compete for the title of 'Mr. Christmas' and the lead in a new Hallmark Christmas movie! Will this reality show steal my heart away from my beloved Christmas movies? And can a reality show truly capture the magic of Christmas?

Photo courtesy of Hallmark Media

Who am I kidding? One episode in, and I was already head over heels for this show! And why wouldn't I be? First of all, Jonathan Bennett! Need I say more? Okay, I will! This man is the absolute perfect host – funny, charming, and he rocks that festive sweater collection like nobody's business! He's the reigning King of Christmas, and I am here for it! And then there's Melissa Peterman, bringing her signature wit and warmth to the judging panel. She's like the sassy, supportive best friend we all need, and her playful banter with Jonathan is pure holiday gold! And the contestants?  We've got the charming Aussie children's entertainer, the guitar-playing firefighter, and the talented stage actor to name a few. Hallmark really outdid themselves with this cast! Each one embodies the qualities of a Hallmark leading man – kindness, charisma, a sense of humor – and their chemistry with Melissa and Jonathan is sparkling like a Christmas tree!

Photo courtesy of Hallmark Media

Now, let's talk about the challenges! First up, the 'Festive Face-off'! Imagine these guys wrestling with wrapping paper and ribbon, trying to create the perfect Christmas bow while the clock is ticking! Or picture them facing off in an ugly sweater design competition, where creativity reigns supreme. And untangling Christmas lights? We've all been there, but watching these guys tackle an eighty-pound tangled mess of twinkling lights is laugh-out-loud funny. Let's just say, patience isn't everyone's strongest suit! But the real highlight? The 'Star Quality Challenge'! Each week, our contestants get to showcase their acting chops, perhaps improvising a skit with Melissa and Hallmark leading man, B.J. Britt, or acting out a romantic scene with Brooke D'Orsay or Rachel Boston!

Photo courtesy of Hallmark Media

Sparks fly, awkward moments abound, and sometimes, true chemistry ignites! But just when they think they've got it figured out, Jonathan and Melissa throw in a surprise twist. One minute they're acting out a romantic scene, and the next, a skater takes a dramatic tumble right in front of them! Will they stop to help? Spoiler alert; most do, but one, sadly does not. And just when they think they can breathe a sigh of relief, they're suddenly thrown into a surprise interview with the one and only Keltie Knight of E! News! These unexpected challenges keep everyone on their toes and reveal who truly has the makings of a Hallmark leading man.

What truly sets Hallmark's 'Finding Mr. Christmas' apart is the genuine connection between the contestants. This isn't your typical reality show where drama and pettiness take center stage. Instead, these men are lifting each other up and celebrating each other's successes. When one contestant struggled with a particularly challenging acting scene, the others rallied around him with words of encouragement and advice. They cheer each other on and offer comfort during disappointments. Seeing these men form such strong bonds in such a short time is incredibly heartwarming. There's a real sense of brotherhood and genuine support that has, I admit, brought a tear to my eye more than once. By the end of each episode, you feel like you've gotten to know these men, and saying goodbye to one of them feels like saying goodbye to a friend.

Photo courtesy of Hallmark Media

Don't get me wrong, I'll be squeezing in plenty of those cheesy, romantic Christmas movies (because let's face it, I adore those snow-covered kisses and heartwarming happy endings!). But 'Finding Mr. Christmas' has stolen a piece of my heart, and I'm on the edge of my seat waiting to see who will capture the crown and star in a future Hallmark movie! So grab a cup of hot cocoa, cozy up by the fire, and join us on Love on the Pod for all the juicy details and behind-the-scenes scoop! And don't miss our grand finale, where we'll be unwrapping all the heartwarming moments from 'Happy Howlidays'—starring the one-and-only Jessica Lowndes and the newly crowned Mr. Christmas himself! It's the perfect way to cap off your holiday season with a dose of love, laughter, and Christmas cheer!

Listen to our recap of 'Finding Mr. Christmas' Episodes 1-3 now!

Listen to Episodes 4-6 here!

Rock your Love on the Pod spirit! Check out our merch store here!